2011 MLB Mock Draft – 5.0

In about 24 hours, a year’s worth of speculation and prognostication will be put to rest and the results will speak for themselves. Until then, enjoy our final mock draft. It’s chock full of speculation.


1. Pittsburgh PiratesDanny Hultzen – LHP – Virginia. 6’2″ 195. Last Drafted: Arizona Diamondbacks – ’08 (10th Round)

Update: Let’s say it came down to a final look between Hultzen and Gerrit Cole. Cole was 7.1IP 11H 3ER 1BB 11K in a Loss to San Francisco while Hultzen was 7IP 3H 1ER 1BB 12K in Win against St. John’s.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Anthony Rendon, 2.22 Anthony Rendon, 5.6 Anthony Rendon, 6.2 Gerrit Cole.


2. Seattle MarinersAnthony Rendon – 3B – Rice. Bats: R Throws: R. 6’0″ 190. Last Drafted: Atlanta Braves – ’08 (27th Round).

Update: Teams now have Rendon’s medical records. If they still have concerns over shoulder, look for Francisco Lindor here.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Matt Purke, 2.22 Gerrit Cole, 5.6 Gerrit Cole, 6.2 Anthony Rendon.


3. Arizona DiamondbacksTrevor Bauer – RHP – UCLA. 6’1″ 175. Last Drafted: Never.

Update: Hultzen if available. If not I think it’s Bauer over Cole.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Gerrit Cole, 2.22 Matt Purke, 5.6 Sonny Gray, 6.2 Danny Hultzen.


4. Baltimore OriolesDylan Bundy – RHP – Owasso HS (OK). 6’1″ 200. College Commitment: Texas.

Update: Bundy makes so much sense, but it’s far from certain. Gerrit Cole would be another possibility here.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Bubba Starling, 2.22 Taylor Jungmann, 5.6 Dylan Bundy, 6.2 Dylan Bundy.


5. Kansas City RoyalsGerrit Cole – RHP – UCLA. 6’4″ 220. Last Drafted: New York Yankees – ’08 (1st Round).

Update: The Royals reportedly covet Cole and would jump on him if he slides.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Taylor Jungmann, 2.22 George Springer, 5.6 Bubba Starling, 6.2 Trevor Bauer.


6. Washington NationalsBubba Starling – OF – Gardner Edgerton HS (KS). Bats: R Throws: R. 6’4″ 180. College Commitment: Nebraska (Football)

Update: Stephen Strasburg, Bryce Harper and Bubba Starling. Some big names for fans to get excited about. Mike Rizzo isn’t afraid to pay.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Daniel Norris, 2.22 Sonny Gray, 5.6 Danny Hultzen, 6.2 Bubba Starling.


7. Arizona Diamondbacks (for failure to sign Barret Loux) – Francisco Lindor – SS – Montverde Academy (FL). Bats: B Throws: R. 5’11” 175. College Commitment: Florida State.

Update: I think Sonny Gray, Matt Barnes and Taylor Jungmann would make sense here assuming they’re singable, but they love Lindor.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Jackie Bradley Jr., 2.22 Jackie Bradley Jr., 5.6 Francisco Lindor, 6.2 Sonny Gray.


8. Cleveland IndiansArchie Bradley – RHP – Broken Arrow HS (OK). 6’4″ 210. College Commitment: Oklahoma.

Update: Cleveland likes taking college arms early and Sonny Gray, Taylor Jungmann, Jed Bradley would make sense, but Archie Bradley is worth breaking from the norm.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 George Springer, 2.22 Archie Bradley, 5.6 Taylor Jungmann, 6.2 Archie Bradley.

9. Chicago CubsSonny Gray – RHP – Vanderbilt. 5’11” 180. Last Drafted: Chicago Cubs – ’08 (27th Round).

Update: The Cubs are a wild card and after 5 months of speculation, I’m back to thinking they’ll take Sonny Gray as they did in 2008. Taylor Guerrieri, Archie Bradley and Francisco Lindor are other popular ties.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Sonny Gray, 2.22 Bubba Starling, 5.6 Taylor Guerrieri, 6.2 George Springer.


10. San Diego Padres (for failure to sign Karsten Whitson) – Matt Barnes – RHP – Connecticut. 6’3″ 180. Last Drafted: Never.

Update: The Padres need to sign this pick and they like Barnes, who’s modest ceiling suggests that he might be singable.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Archie Bradley, 2.22 Matt Barnes, 5.6 Trevor Bauer, 6.2 Matt Barnes.


11. Houston AstrosTaylor Jungmann – RHP – Texas. 6’6″ 195. Last Drafted: Los Angeles Angles – ’08 (24th Round)

Update: Jumgmann could be the NCAA Player of the Year. Other options for this pick include Gray, Barnes, Jed Bradley and any other college arm that slips.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Dillon Howard, 2.22 Daniel Norris, 5.6 Archie Bradley, 6.2 Taylor Jungmann.


12. Milwaukee BrewersJed Bradley – LHP – Georgia Tech. 6’3″ 205. Last Drafted: Never.

Update: If it’s not a college arm, I think it’s either Lindor or Javier Baez.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Matt Barnes, 2.22 Dylan Bundy, 5.6 Jed Bradley, 6.2 Jed Bradley.


13. New York MetsTaylor Guerrieri – RHP – Spring Valley HS (SC). 6’3″ 180. College Commitment: South Carolina.

Update: I’ve been all over the place for the Mets. Now I’m thinking either college arms (would love Sonny Gray) or Taylor Guerrieri, who trails only Bundy and Bradley in the prep arms ranking.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 John Stilson, 2.22 Francisco Lindor, 5.6 George Springer, 6.2 Levi Michael.


14. Florida MarlinsMikie Mahtook – OF – LSU. 6’1″ 205. Bats: R Throws: R. Last Drafted: Florida Marlins ’08 (39th Round).

Update: Marlins have a history with Mahtook, whom they selected in 2008.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Dylan Bundy, 2.22 Jed Bradley, 5.6 Daniel Norris, 6.2 Mikie Mahtook.


15. Milwaukee Brewers (for failure to sign Dylan Covey) – Levi Michael – SS – North Carolina. 5’10” 180. Bats: B Throws: R. Last Drafted: Never.

Update: This pick needs to be singable. Michael fits the bill.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Trevor Bauer, 2.22 Trevor Bauer, 5.6 Matt Barnes, 6.2 Cory Spangenberg


16. Los Angeles DodgersRobert Stephenson – RHP – Alhambra HS (CA). 6’2″ 185. College Commitment: Washington.

Update: All indications are that the Dodgers won’t be permitted to go over slot and that Stephenson is signable. A perfect marriage, which is rare for the Dodgers.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Danny Hultzen, 2.22 Danny Hultzen, 5.6 Anthony Meo, 6.2 Javier Baez


17. Los Angeles AngelsJavier Baez – SS/3B – Arlington Country Day HS (FL). 6’1″ 205. College Commitment: Chipola JC.

Update: This would be Lindor’s floor. I think they take Baez or a prep arm (Dillon Howard, Henry Owens, Daniel Norris).

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Blake Swihart, 2.22 Blake Swihart, 5.6 Blake Swihart, 6.2 Francisco Lindor


18. Oakland AthleticsGeorge Springer – OF – Connecticut. Bats: R Throws: R. 6’3″ 205. Last Drafted: Minnesota Twins ’08 (48th Round)

Update: It’s going to be a college bat here and my previous two predictions Mahtook and C.J. Cron are still in play, but the slide of Springer will end here.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Josh Bell, 2.22 Anthony Meo, 5.6 Mikie Mahtook, 6.2 C.J. Cron.


19. Boston Red Sox (from Tigers for Victor Martinez) – Alex Meyer – RHP – Kentucky. 6’9″ 210. Last Drafted: Boston Red Sox. ’08 (20th Round).

Update: I appear to be relying heavily historical ties between players in my final mock. Gray to Cubs, Mahtook to Florida and now Meyer to Boston.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Francisco Lindor, 2.22 Jason Esposito, 5.6 Alex Meyer, 6.2 Alex Meyer.


20. Colorado RockiesC.J. Cron – 1B – Utah – Jr. Bats: R Throws: R. 6’4″ 230. Last Drafted: Chicago White Sox ’08 (44th Round).

Update: Wong still in play here but Cron has proved to be one of the better college bats in this draft.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Tyler Anderson, 2.22 Dillon Howard, 5.6 Dillon Howard, 6.2 Kolten Wong.


21. Toronto Blue JaysAndrew Chafin – LHP – Kent State. 6’2″ 190. Last Drafted: Never.

Update: Toronto has been linked to Chafin and after beating Taylor Jungmann and Texas on Saturday, I no longer think he’ll be available in the supplemental round.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Jason Esposito, 2.22 Tyler Anderson, 5.6 Tyler Anderson, 6.2 Tyler Anderson.


22. St. Louis CardinalsJose Fernandez – RHP – Alonso HS (FL). 6’3″ 230. College Commitment: South Florida.

Update: Dillon Howard, Daniel Norris and Henry Owens all possibilities here.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Derek Fisher, 2.22 John Stilson, 5.6 Jackie Bradley Jr., 6.2 Taylor Guerrieri.


23. Washington Nationals (from White Sox for Adam Dunn) – Tyler Anderson – LHP – Oregon. 6’3″ 195. Last Drafted: Never.

Update: Maintaining my comment from Mock 4.0 “If Alex Meyer were to slip, the Nats would select him before the Cardinals left the podium“.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Alex Meyer, 2.22 Josh Bell, 5.6 Josh Bell, 6.2 Dillon Howard.


24. Tampa Bay Rays (from Red Sox for Carl Crawford) – Kolten Wong – 2B – Hawaii. Bats: L Throws: R. 5’8″ 175. Last Drafted: Minnesota Twins – ’08 (16th Round)

Update: With 12 picks in the top two rounds, the Rays will need to mix in some affordable safe players. Wong is just that.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Brandon Nimmo, 2.22 Henry Owens, 5.6 Henry Owens, 6.2 Henry Owens.


25. San Diego PadresCory Spangenberg – 3B/OF – Indian River State College. 6’0″ 185. Bats: L Throws: R. Last Drafted: Never

Update: I wouldn’t rule out the Pads using the 10th overall pick on Spandenberg, so they’d love it if he fell here.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Anthony Meo, 2.22 Kolten Wong, 5.6 Andrew Susac, 6.2 Andrew Susac.


26. Boston Red Sox (from Rangers for Adrian Beltre) – Blake Swihart – C – Cleveland HS (NM). Bats: B Throws: R. 6’0″ 175. College Commitment: Texas.

Update: The Red Sox could take a shot at Josh Bell, who recently asked MLB teams not to draft him. Swihart is another expensive prep star and the Red Sox might even take him at #19.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Jose Fernandez, 2.22 Jose Fernandez, 5.6 Jose Fernandez, 6.2 Josh Bell.


27. Cincinnati RedsGrayson Garvin – LHP – Vanderbilt. 6’6″ 220. Last Drafted: Houston Astros – ’08 (45th Round).

Update: Cincinnati would love for Tyler Anderson, Jed Bradley to fall. Florida State’s Sean Gilmartin and Oregon State’s Josh Osich are other possibilities. Left handed college pitching seems to be the theme.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Alex Dickerson, 2.22 Alex Dickerson, 5.6 Levi Michael, 6.2 Brian Goodwin.


28. Atlanta BravesDaniel Norris – LHP – Science Hill HS (TN). 6’3″ 180. College Commitment: Clemson.

Update: Henry Owens is another possibility. A sleeper here would be Tennessee prep product Nickey Delmonico.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Zach Cone, 2.22 Zach Cone, 5.6 Brian Goodwin, 6.2 Jose Fernandez.


29. San Francisco GiantsJoe Ross – RHP – Bishop O’Dowd HS (CA). 6’2″ 180. College Commitment: UCLA.

Update: Strong link here but Keith Law has Ross going as high as #9.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Jed Bradley, 2.22 Brian Goodwin, 5.6 Jason Esposito, 6.2 Daniel Norris.


30. Minnesota TwinsAndrew Susac – C – Oregon State. 6’1″ 205. Bats: R Throws: R. Last Drafted: Philadelphia Phillies – ’09 (16th Round).

Update: Nobody knows what Minnesota is thinking. Also linked to low ceiling, high floor college pitchers.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Noe Ramirez, 2.22 Brandon Nimmo, 5.6 Nicky Delmonico, 6.2 Blake Swihart.


31. Tampa Bay Rays – (From Yankees for Raphael Soriano) – Brandon Nimmo – OF – Cheyenne (WY). 6’3″ 185. Bats: L Throws: R. College Commitment: Arkansas

Update: I still like the Nimmo link, as I’ve been on it since early May.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Logan Verrett, 2.22 Andrew Susac, 5.6 Brandon Nimmo, 6.2 Brandon Nimmo.


32. Tampa Bay RaysHenry Owens – LHP – Edison HS Huntington Beach (CA). 6’5″ 185. College Commitment: Miami (FL).

Update: This would work out well for Tampa. Assuming they go bat, bat with their first two picks, Owens would be a coveted pitcher at this point.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Charlie Tilson, 2.22 Alex Meyer, 5.6 John Stilson, 6.2 Robert Stephenson


33. Texas Rangers (From Phillies for Cliff Lee) – Austin Hedges – C – J. Serra (CA). Bats: R Throws: R. 6’1″ 190. College Commitment: UCLA.

Update: Extremely advanced glove for a prep backstop. Modest ceiling with the bat.

Previous Mocks: 1.17 Mikie Mahtook, 2.22 Mikie Mahtook, 5.6 Charlie Tilson, 6.2 Austin Hedges.

Fallen Out:

Dillon Howard – RHP – Searcy HS (AR). 6’2″ 200. College Commitment: Arkansas.

Brian Goodwin – OF – Miami Dade JC. 6’1″ 190. Bats: L Thorws: R. Last Drafted – Chicago White Sox – ’09 (17th Round).

Josh Bell – OF – Jesuit Prep School of Dallas (TX). Bats: B Throws: R. 6’3″ 205. College Commitment: Texas.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s